Patience in the midst of volatility is a challenge. Too often, mutual fund shareholders become nervous and make ill-advised changes because they can’t accept temporary declines.
Typically, investors who do best stick with the basic program through thick and thin.
The top diversified stock funds in average annual return in the last 10 years rewarded hardy souls who left money where it was, no matter what. Viewed in hindsight, a brilliant non-move.
"Hitting singles and doubles is fun and hitting home runs even better," said Tom Roseen, senior research analyst with Lipper Inc. in Denver. "But if you find a fund that hits triples all the time, you’ll always be in scoring position."
Longevity of management is key to funds that are successful and consistent long-term. The top six stock funds in the last 10-year period kept the same lead managers running the show throughout that period, Roseen said. Even the two newest managers among the 10 best-performing funds have been in their positions for five years.
Steady strategy instills understanding, trust and patience in shareholders. Of course, investment climate makes a difference, too.
"The list of top 10-year performers has mid- and small-cap funds on it, but no large caps," Roseen said. "We’ve come off a period when small- and mid-cap stocks have been very popular, while large cap has been a pariah since the 2000-2002 market decline."
The consistent characteristic of the top fund of the last 10 years is the fearless confidence of manager Kenneth Heebner, in charge since its inception in 1997. His CGM Focus Fund in Boston has a 10-year annualized return of 25 percent.
Heebner makes big bets, often owns less than 25 stock names and shifts among market caps. His short position, or a bet that a stock will decline, in subprime lender Countrywide Financial and his shares of Chinese oil firm CNOOC helped produce an 80 percent gain last year.
"I concentrate," Heebner said. "When I run this fund I’m looking at opportunities and then concentrating the fund where those opportunities are."
Focusing on a small number of stocks can be risky because of potential damage if several holdings tank. He also trades a lot, generating significant capital-gains tax liability.
Heebner insists that he is fully aware of what could go wrong, "and I act very quickly on problems." He is constantly researching, studying global trends and trying to learn from mistakes.
"I don’t even attempt to time individual stocks because I don’t know how someone could do it," he said. "I wouldn’t begin to know what the short-term fluctuations of my fund are going to be year to year, and I know all the stocks that are in it."
Faith in Heebner’s fund requires faith in his ingenuity.
Faith in micro-cap stocks is another matter. Those smaller companies with market capitalization between $30 million and $300 million are frenetic because they represent unproven firms faxless payday loans. Buckling in for the last 10 years produced a wild ride.
"While we do have phenomenal 10-year numbers for our micro-cap fund, I wonder how many investors really got those numbers," said O. Thomas Barry III, senior portfolio manager for Bjurman, Barry Micro-Cap Growth Fund in Los Angeles, with 10-year annualized return of 16 percent. "They tend to get in at the top, sell after a sell-off and dip back in after it runs up again."
In the last 100 years, annual return of the micro-cap group has been 18.8 percent, outpacing the 11.6 percent of large caps, noted Barry, referencing data from the Center for Research in Security Prices at the University of Chicago.
Barry employs five investment screens to find firms with the fastest earnings growth selling for low price-earnings ratios relative to that growth. Big winners included Andersons Inc. in grain elevators and ethanol, Healthcare Services Group Inc. in housekeeping services and Metal Management Inc. in scrap-metal recycling.
"Micro-caps do well over time, but have periods of three to five years when they underperform," said Barry, whose fund declined by 1 percent last year. "When investors hear bad news about the economy, they gravitate toward the least-risky securities — the large caps — which are less volatile but don’t match long-term returns of micro-caps."
The top diversified stock mutual funds in 10-year annualized total return, according to Lipper:
•CGM Focus Fund, no "load" or initial sales charge; $2,500 minimum initial investment; annualized return 25 percent
•Quaker Strategic Growth Fund "A," 5.5 percent load; $2,000 minimum; 18 percent
•Bjurman, Barry Micro-Cap Growth Fund, no load; $1,000 minimum; 16 percent
•Meridian Value Fund, no load; $1,000 minimum; 15 percent
•Security Mid Cap Value Series "A," 5.75 percent load; $1,000 minimum; 15 percent
•Royce Heritage Service Fund, no load; $2,000 minimum; 14 percent
•MTB Small Cap Growth Fund "A," 5.5 percent load; $500 minimum; 14 percent
•Needham Growth Fund, no-load; $5,000 minimum; 14 percent
•Security Mid Cap Value Series "B," 5 percent deferred load; $100 minimum; 14 percent
•Royce Opportunity Fund; Investment, no-load; $2,000 minimum; 14 percent.
Funds closed to new investors or requiring high minimum initial investments were excluded. Always monitor the recent annual returns of the funds as well.
andrewinv@aol.com
2008, TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.
Source